Okay, so the obvious answer is yes. You can freeze just about anything. Maybe a better question would be, is it a good idea to freeze cheese?
We froze 3 different kinds of cheese: Philadelphia Nuefchâtel (I called it Cream Cheese in the video, almost the same thing), Tillamook Medium Cheddar, and Pecorino Romano. Some of the Cheddar was pre-shredded.
We also had the same 3 cheeses in our refrigerator for the same amount of time.
Five days later, we thawed the frozen cheese for a few hours, and voilà, here's the first video:
I didn't notice it when I was filming the first video, but the shredded frozen cheese had jagged edges, the non-frozen had smoother edges. (Click to see larger versions of the photos below.)
With the Nuefchâtel (cream cheese), the one on the left had been frozen, then thawed. It did not want to stick together when using a knife to spread it on crackers.
Of all three cheeses, the Pecorino Romano surprised me the most. I thought since it was the hardest of the three cheeses, it would stand up to freezing better than the other two. But it looked different shredded, and didn't melt as well. The cheese in the photo below on the left had been frozen, then thawed, then shredded. The one on the right had never been frozen.
After my block of frozen Cheddar thawed, I shot another video, to see if it shredded as well as the Cheddar from the fridge. In the first video, the frozen Cheddar shredded pretty easily. Not as easy once it had been thawed.
And even after it thawed, the frozen Cheddar had a coloration difference. In the photo below, the one on the left had been frozen, and thawed. The one on the right, never frozen.
So, does it melt?
I wanted to see if freezing cheese altered the way it melted. I tried with the Tillamook Cheddar and with the Pecorino Romano.
In the photos below, the one on the left is frozen, then thawed, then grated Pecorino Romano. The one on the right has Pecorino Romano that had never been frozen. The frozen, thawed cheese did not melt as well, and seperated somewhat when heating.
In the photo below, the Cheddar on the left had been frozen, then shredded. The Cheddar in the middle was shredded before it was frozen. The Cheddar on the right had never been frozen. They looked the same, melted at about the same rate. I had quesadillas with all my extra cheese, and could not tell the difference between the frozen and never frozen cheese.
In a nutshell
Here's what I found from my cheese melting experiment:
- If presentation is important, do not freeze the cheese.
- If you want to shred it, shred it before you freeze it, or shred it while it's still frozen.
- Freezing cheese affects the texture more than the taste. I couldn't tell a difference in taste, but possibly someone with better taste buds could.
- Some cheeses do better in the freezer than others. I wouldn't freeze Pecorino Romano.